The UK is Out - New PM - and whither now for Article 50

13468984

Comments

  • An example of the shambles being the insane amount of paperwork bureaucracy and compliance required to trade with an EU company, where las there is none at all to trade with a Chinese company

    Serious question, why do you think that the amount of bureaucracy and compliance would reduce because we are no longer in the EU.

    We would still be dealing with the EU, we just wouldn't be in the EU.
  • Mooj

    Have you ever completed intrastat returns, Eu sales lists, reverse charging on vat returns, etc etc?

    None of these are required for trading with a Chinese or Swiss company, etc etc
  • Mooj

    Have you ever completed intrastat returns, Eu sales lists, reverse charging on vat returns, etc etc?

    None of these are required for trading with a Chinese or Swiss company, etc etc

    No I haven't which is why I asked. So those are required purely because we are in the EU.

    Such as the OJEU is (Offical Journal of the European Union) which, if we left the EU, we would no longer comply with and therefore be able to tender out public spending jobs just to companies in the UK.

    Actually, thinking about it, that could be a boost to British jobs, public spending could be fullfilled by British companies instead of having to open up tenders across the EU.


  • Personally I'll take business leaders' informed and expert view of what is likely to happen to businesses and the economy over any politician or newspaper baron.

    .

    Rightly we should take anything a newspaper or politician says with a huge pinch of salt. But conversely I'm of the belief that the ftse bosses are a little cosy club unto themselves and will often scratch each other's backs and the backs of senior politicians.

    Not dissimilar to the love in between George Osborne and the boss of Google uk
  • Grey just out of interest, the "we" you refer to is what exactly. Greece where you live or the UK where you don't live.
    It has seemed to me from the posts on here that all the expats living in Europe want the UK to stay in but I don't see how the UK voting to leave would affect them directly. If, say, Italy wanted to leave I wouldn't necessarily be campaigning for them to remain because I can't see how it directly impacts on me.
  • edited February 2016
    But if you were Italian, thorn? It would affect you as an Italian in the UK that was outside the EU?
  • Just out of interest - for any that have access to BBC Iplayer - on Newsnight there is a montage of documentaries made by Michael Cockerell in 1975. Some startlingly clear similarities, and differences!

    Loved the bit from Lord McAlpine (who was yes campaign treasurer) - "we used to meet at the Dorchester because a member of my family owned it" - "the budget (for the campaign) was unlimited, money just poured in and we only spent about half of it"
  • edited February 2016
    Thorn

    Referring to myself and MrsGrey (hence 'personally')

    Free European movement means we have the right to live in Greece without any papers beyond our passport.

    In addition, I believe that a UK exit would negatively affect the pound against the Euro (it's already tanked 15 cents in the last 3 months)

    For me, whilst the EU organisation is far from perfect, the UK being in it doesn't seem to do us (as in UK citizens) any harm, whilst doing some good.

    As I said earlier, I feel it is for the No campaign to offer convincing proof that life outside the EU would benefit the majority of UK citizens.

    If they can, I'll vote no, but otherwise, it's yes, assuming I am eligible...
  • edited February 2016
    If the UK were to leave the EU, then we (me and grey) would be potentially be affected by ..

    new Greek residency rules/requirements, paperwork, possibly visas

    changes to rules on taxation (currently the EU system aims to stop 'double taxation')

    possible changes to rule for UK citizens to work or own property in Greece

    Would there be changes to vehicle ownership rules/drivers licensing?

    Transferring money from UK bank accounts to our Greek bank account is simple - transfers within EU are easy - if UK was out, how would that work?

    Internet shopping from companies in UK - currently no customs charges, import duties etc because UK is part of EU.

    Medical treatment at state clinics/hospitals would presumably be stopped....


  • All plenty of reasons why the Greys would probably want to stay "in" and I for one wouldn't blame them.

    ;ok
  • Yeah, but that's not all I'm going to base it on, though. Especially as what the 'out future' would look like on a personal level is difficult to know. (Although Brits who were here pre-EU can offer a fairly good idea.) ;ok
  • Greys thanks for clarifying what you meant although some of your points still contain more than a modicum of hypothesis and unknowns.
    I am one of those who know what it was like pre our joining the EU and given that should the vote be to leave it will take years to determine how it will work I may well not be around when it finally comes to pass so may not be able to enlighten you as to how pre joining and post leaving compares.
  • thorn .. and even looking back to pre-EU days, well the world is a different place now so we don't know that the future will be like the past (if 'out') ;ok

  • Thorn ;ok that is really where my comments were coming from, I think it will take years for the affects of an out vote to be felt.
  • MrsGrey said:

    Yeah, but that's not all I'm going to base it on, though. Especially as what the 'out future' would look like on a personal level is difficult to know. (Although Brits who were here pre-EU can offer a fairly good idea.) ;ok

    I was clearly fishing for a like or two

    What more does man have to do ;lol
  • A key question that surely is the heart of the debate is the freedom of movement across EU and can we absorb anymore economic migration can our infrastructure take anymore pressure hospitals education etc. Will the new living wage add to it in no way do I want to seem insular and blame the ills of our country on migration however it is an issue at the heart of it does this outweigh perhaps the economic negatives of leaving sadly I doubt whether thus question will be rationally qualified both sides will manipulate stats to suit there arguments and migrants will feel more villified and blamed
    TBH I do think there is a problem
    With free movement only because EU is a 3 tier system wealth and economic wise and this does put a strain on the richer economies and because some countries have free healthcare more generous benifits higher standard of living it attracts mainly unskilled workers but I do not pretend I have the answer call me Dave certainily hasnt negotiated anything better but it is a fact that it is a problem ;ok
  • However as I stated earlier in 75 I was 3 months to young to vote but would have voted out but my gut feeling is 40 years later we are too integrated now and OUT is no longer possible or realistic ;ok
  • Aka

    The way George Osborne deals with the creaking NHS and education systems is to continually rip the heart out of "middle England" - they are the ones expected to pay for it.
  • Agree Baraks but do low paid migrants contribute enough through taxes and with tax credits etc is it too much a strain ;ok
  • I notice the BBC news making a big thing about the 36 Footsie 100 members decided to focus on O2. A bit ironic as O2 is owned by Telefonica a German company. Is it a surprise that they would urge people to vote to stay in?
  • It is interesting reading everyone's thoughts and views and also heartening to know that the majority on here are giving it proper consideration and not just making knee jerk reactions which I was worried too many people would do.

    At the moment I am still on the fence. Part of me thinks that we are better to stay in and try to help reform the EU from within. Although the cynic in me thinks that we will never get anywhere and that too often it seems that Germany or France block what may be best for us.

    It is that which then makes me think we would be better off on our own as we can then regain some of the powers that we seem to have lost. But at the same time I don't want us to become a small minded nation closed off to the rest of the world. I also don't want the average person on the street to be left worse off if the EU makes our exit difficult for us.

    It is very important for us to find the right balance in retaining our culture and heritage but also contributing, adapting and helping lead the world forward to be a better place for all. I think that London will always be a multicultural city that will draw people in from all over the world. I also think that with new technology and advances coming in if we were to exit it would be easier to remain connected still. Things like visa's and banking are already online and I can only see that becoming more so in the future. If we do leave we will still be a world player but would we be more so if we stayed in?

    I was hoping that by writing this down it might help me swing one way more than the other, however for each argument/point I make I can find a counter argument. I think my biggest fear is that each politician or member state of the EU is out to do what is best for them or gives them the most power and not what is alway best for the most people in the long term.

    I hope that one day we reach a point that we as a collective always look to do what is best, however unfortunately I don't think that we will ever be rid of the horrible flaw in human nature that is greed which almost always leads to corruption. Anyway that is heading off topic now so will end my ramblings.
  • A point I noticed was the Polish PM stating the Cameron deal was far better for Poland and the U.K and Merkle admitting that she and Europe conceded virtually nothing. That's down to Cameron stating at the outset that he wants to stay in whatever the outcome. The Baldrick method of bartering and negotiation.
  • Dear Angela

    As you know, I'm more than happy for our nation to continue serving under yours.

    However, please can you help me create the impression to my gullible electorate that I have really battled hard and secured some fantastic concessions for the UK - ones which my all time idol Margaret Thatcher would have been proud of. Of course I'm more than happy, as discussed for these then to be rescinded as soon as possible, but I just need to get this annoying June 23rd thing out of the way.

    Yours always

    (Call me) Dave
  • My tuppence worth is that Britain in the EU, but with special exemptions, and a lot of autonomy, will have the same end-result as Britain outside the EU, but with special partnerships and "favoured nation" status. Whether you get a nametag and a party hat, you're still invited to the street party. Putting it bluntly, if the quality of life goes up or down by a few hundred pounds per year, in all likelihood, it won't be because of any other country's influence. EU membership will not affect intelligence sharing, either, so any argument about national security is a load of gentlemen's reproductive organs. Vote in or out, the UK will always be what it is. A separate part of Europe. That's what makes you special! ;hug
  • Really interesting QT last night good point about this is not a question of economics or immigration but democracy ;bowdown

    An observation time and time again Pro mention trading with Europe and it part of Global economy yet my understanding is that global economy is all about world free trade ending tariffs etc which is slowly progressing so ;cake and eat comes to mind

    Although my instincts are out I have come to a unique solution I shall ask my Children what they intend to vote for and follow majority decision I feel at 58
    The outcome is not going to overly affect me and this is a long term thing so I owe it to them luckily Ive got 3 so it cant be level vote ;ok
  • Human rights, worker rights etc. are also part of democracy and the EU provides accountability to ensure those standards and values are kept. I don't trust this government to not take us backwards in this regard if we abandon the ECHR.
  • MrsGrey said:

    imagelost said:


    Stop scare mongring
    Give proof are shut up

    Is that addressed to people on here, or politicians?



    If politicians, is it addressed to both sides or just one?
    Mp's
  • Perhaps Outcast but point they are making us that it should be UK decision dont think
    Our HR were that bad kept banging on about workers rights have they having a giraffe I just TUPE lost my pension ;angry
  • Government's paper on possible models if the UK leaves the EU, including their reasons why they think it would not be a benefit.

    https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/504604/Alternatives_to_membership_-_possible_models_for_the_UK_outside_the_EU.pdf
  • Squeeky bum time tomorrow
This discussion has been closed.