Summer 2017 Transfer Speculation (continued)

13335373839

Comments

  • Probably a bit short of attacking mids/wingers now and still lacking a defensive midfielder
  • edited August 2017
    I think Masuaku can be converted/is good enough as a winger if needed. I also believe Byram could also do a job as a wide midfield player.
  • I think Masuaku can be converted/is good enough as a winger if needed. I also believe Byram could also do a job as a wide midfield player.

    Played alot of his football at Leeds as a right mid. ;thumbsup
  • I'd rather not keep persisting with "could do a job at..."

    I've just read a transcript of snodgrass' glowing review of his experience at West Ham. Says that he played his best scoring and creating as either a number 10 or on the right

    Yet according to him slav insisted on playing on the left in payet's position

    Pretty damning. He was just one of those who came to West Ham in decent form and withered under slav.
  • edited August 2017
    He was never going to play in those positions though, given the number of players we had for those. He shouldn't have come if he thought he would.

    And he wasn't any better when he did play on the right.
  • Just not good enough. He did have a lot of mins on the right. Never did anything.
  • Antonio played on the left to accommodate him at times and he was dreadful. Sounds like he's trying to justify to the Villa fans that he isn't a waste of time.
  • alderz said:

    Snodgrass played on the left to accommodate him at times and he was dreadful. Sounds like he's trying to justify to the Villa fans that he isn't a waste of time.

    Fixed it for you. :)
  • If it wasnt clear, I meant Antonio played on the left to leave space on the right for Snodgrass, and Snodgrass was still terrible
  • I agree, he was, indeed.
  • Probably a bit short of attacking mids/wingers now and still lacking a defensive midfielder

    And luck
    And lacking morale fibres
    And lacking the will to win
    And
    That ado donkay that ado
  • Rob Green has signed for Huddersfield.
  • WIth the result on Saturday casting huge doubts on Bilic's future, I can't see G&S splashing out a new club record fee for a player that a new manager might not want, regardless of how desperately we need him.

    Too little time now to get a new manager in and secure his targets before the window closes, so, if they are thinking seriously about getting rid of Bilic, I think they'll keep that cash to make available to a new managr in January or next summer.

    It's kinda chicken and egg though, because if they don't spend the cash on Carvalho then it's much more likely they'll replace Bilic; if they'd have signed him pre-season there might not even be talk of Bilic going.
  • Palace alledgely interested in fonte
  • but would we have to pay Palace to take him ;whistle
  • Football just isn't fair imo

    Psg signing neymar for £200mil and getting Mbappe on loan to buy for £166mil

    City spent over £200mil
    United £150mil
    Liveprool have spent £40mil but have had a bid accepted fro Keita and maybe Lear

    Whereas we have spent £40mil (recouping £30mil of it) yet can't seem to push some moves across

    Just wish we could go back a couple years and change so that the Abu Dhabi group bought us instead of city
  • debt should already be paid off

    External has, internal is 60m to owners including interest and 40m ish to other clubs which most clubs carry

    It's not that we won't pay the money it's the way the deal is structured that SL are being difficult about and if we don't have enough to pay at the initial signing then we've probably not got enough cash on hand
  • edited August 2017
    James T got injured Saturday for Palace so would be good to offload fonte whilst he has a value. Sure we can recall burke should the need arise.
  • edited August 2017
    I feel like selling James Tomkins was a bit like selling Collins the first time (without the following relegation hopefully). All these players we've brought in and no one's been any better than he was.
  • Was it Tomkins that was supposed to be marking their guy for the first goal?
  • It usually was... ;whistle
  • IMO Tomkins was/ is an average CB...
    He in the last few seasons has become very injury prone...
  • Football just isn't fair imo

    Psg signing neymar for £200mil and getting Mbappe on loan to buy for £166mil

    City spent over £200mil
    United £150mil
    Liveprool have spent £40mil but have had a bid accepted fro Keita and maybe Lear

    Whereas we have spent £40mil (recouping £30mil of it) yet can't seem to push some moves across

    Just wish we could go back a couple years and change so that the Abu Dhabi group bought us instead of city

    The difference is that they're all in European competitions and we're not
  • Too late to hope we will bring anyone of quality in the clubs a shambles imo.
  • edited August 2017
    You just said on another thread that you think the squad is ok. ;puzzled
  • The Squad is ok imo , what i'm saying is we have supposedly been linked with a quality defensive midfielder for 3 weeks Bilic admitted to this but as is always the case our owner will not meet the fee being asked as we do everything on the cheap
    so getting quality in is one thing leaving it this late after the shower of the last 3
    games is a joke , if he new he needed this type of player which its clear we do then why leave it this late again .

    Yes I do think we have a decent team it just needs coaching watching the Newcastle game i found it hard to believe we had any sort of game plan .

    And taking Rice off at half time was a stupid thing to do to the kids confidence
    imo .
  • According to Twitter chatter, we're still hopeful of landing Carvalho but are not close to any other deal.

    If we believe SB when he said we would replace anyone who leaves, we must be looking at a wide player to replace Snodgrass. With Feghouli also being sold, we are very light on the wings (particularly risky when you consider Arnie's temperament and Antonio's muscle-testing style of play), and I think it's fair to say Fernandes is not the answer out wide.
  • brookings

    as is always the case our owner will not meet the fee being asked as we do everything on the cheap
    Why say that when you know it isn't true?

    Ayew and Arnie broke the club transfer record.

    We agreed a fee for Bacca last year, but he wouldn't join us.

    Our comparative transfer spend has been posted on a number of occasions, but you ignore that.

    I don't see the point.
  • Grey ;ok we broke the transfer record at west ham ;biggrin we didnt get messi though did we , joking aside my point will always be these two are just sucking the club dry imo , we are getting 57k through the door and our record transfer is 24m
    Leicester paid 34m for a striker last season are we not a bigger club than them.

    Net spend is what i look at we had payet money from january or at least half of it
    we got 120m and net spend is about 36m very poor when you look at other teams around us .
  • 57k but what are they paying for their tickets?

    Are we a bigger club than Leicester? Define "bigger". Have we ever won the Premier league?
This discussion has been closed.