Some positive signs but the same disappointing result. Poor goals to concede and forwards off target. We had chances but didn't take them. Defence leaky and conceding NINE goals in the last two games, and 39 so far is shameful. Only Only Southampton and Leicester have a worse goal difference. We have talented players but not a good manager. Need a change.
Played pretty well imo untill we made comical mistakes that led to goals
Players need to take some responsibility, awful finishing and brain dead mistakes at the back are happening week in week out but same time Lopetegui is telling them to play from the back even though they can't and therefore it's on him to find new ways
Think both are to blame, but you can't sack the players
Wouldn't surprise me if he gets sacked, still think we aren't really at risk of relegation this season as we beat a lot of teams as good as us, we just get annihilated by the better teams
If he stays I'm OK with it, if he leaves in ok with it, but I'd prefer qe get someone new in the summer, so I'd rather we take our time finding the "right" guy then bringing back Moyes or give it to Potter or cooper who I'm not keen on
I have always “felt” that Potter would have been the right fit, I find it hard to believe he was not approached as he was clearly qualified and available so I can only presume that there is a reason his appointment was not pursued.
Maybe it’s just me but I really don’t see us as fighting that relegation battle. I think we’ll pick up enough points to be clear.
I don’t think we will be relegated but if we don’t pick up some.points over the next couple of games we could be in a relegation fight which is a shame because after the European years I thought we had progressed beyond that.
I have always “felt” that Potter would have been the right fit, I find it hard to believe he was not approached as he was clearly qualified and available so I can only presume that there is a reason his appointment was not pursued.
I think in the summer he was still being paid a very healthy salary by Chelsea, one that he would lose if he joined us and one that we wouldn't match. Since then I believe he has reached a final settlement with Chelsea so he's got more incentive to take up a new post.
It obviously depends on the contract - in many industries the employer is contracted to provide or guarantee a level of renumeration for a set period of time, the employee is free to accept employment at a lower salary with the difference still being provided by the originating employer.
I would imagine that football manager contracts are more tightly written but seeing that Chelsea let him go, I doubt that they would restrict his ability to take ongoing employment, even for a competitor
Also a bit worrying that Potter is coming on 2 years without a job
Doubt hes had zero offers, think there couod be some concern he's either just focused on the money or he may not even wanna do the job anymore, booth of which I don't think I'd want in a manager
Yea we could get the Potter of Brighton.... but you couod argue we didn't get the Lopetegui of Wolves so think there is a valid concern there
So more motivated by money than wanting to be back in management. ( If that's true, I mean.)
No more so than, say, Ings who has been happy to stay here getting next to no football rather than taking a pay cut to go somewhere where he'd get regular football.
Ings ( any player) signs a contract in which he agrees to - be contracted to a club - do his job ( ie turn up to training) - keep up certain professional standards (such as diet, weight, punctuality, lifestyle).
In return, club pays agreed wages. There's no guarantee of games - it's up to the manager's judgement.
It's not like he's taking money to loll about in Dubai. Or he's shirking training. He's doing his job, and part of the job is being a squad player. If we took your idea on board, we'd say every player who wasn't being picked in the starting 11 on a regular basis was only interested in the ££££. Clearly that's not true.
In the Potter case, he signed a contract to manage Chelsea ( with whatever criteria involved). Which he did. Chelsea wanted appoint a different manager despite being contractually bound to pay Potter's wages. So they did- both, as they had 2 contracts in place.
Potter, not a football manager any more, was being given money by Chelsea. But he wasn't carrying out any of his contractual obligations, as he had been relieved of them.
I genuinely believed thoughts of ever being in danger of relegation were for the past. The facts are, we are where we are, but are seriously underperforming based on the talent within the squad we can create more chances on the opposition until the cows come home it's not the first time (Leicester City away) and the EPL is littered with hard luck stories of gallant efforts by teams who end up going down. We need to do something now or do we just write the season off and then come up with the same excuses for the next manager that he needs time to instill his playing style & that is why we are below half way!
I would suggest we play the side we had today again on Friday - with the exception of Mavropanos in for Todibo & Emerson in for Coufal (Fab can return to). If Lop is happy with a lot of the things we did today & the ‘good’ things we showed, he needs to settle on the 11 & allow them to continue to build chemistry. Coufal struggled today, so did Areola & Todibo got injured, but keep the rest of the side the same.
This is the new side now; Todibo, Kilman, Wan-Bissaka, Summerville, Füllkrug - all started today. Half the outfield are new signings & yet we are showing no signs of progression or developing in 6 months in terms of attack or defence. Yes, more of the ball. Yes, some nice patterns of play. Yes, more shots in games where historically we’d struggle to have one. But it needs to be more.
We'll have to agree to disagree then MrsG; you said Potter is more motivated by money than management, I say Ings is more motivated by money than playing football. If Ings wanted to be playing, he could take a pay cut and play, but he's chosen to sit on our bench and barely play. He turns up for training, he happily sits on the bench, and he takes his really big pay packet knowing that he's very unlikely to get many minutes. If he was more motivated by playing rather than money, he'd take a pay cut to get regular football elsewhere. Btw, I'm not singling out Ings, as many pros do it; it's not their fault a club offers silly money then decides they are surplus to requirement, but there's little incentive to accept a lower wage elsewhere unless they are more motivated by playing than money.
Ings is coming to the end of his playing career. Of course he’s not going anywhere else for less money. He has his family and future to think about. A manager can continue managing well into their golden years.
I didn’t see the full game today, but have seen the highlights. I didn’t think we looked that bad. We create chances, but just can’t finish. I also think most of the goals we concede seem to be the result of individual errors. Are these really down to the manager? It could be said he’s not picking the right team, but the players need to step up for whoever is in charge. I’m no fan of J-Lo, but is there anyone available out there who we know would get more from these players? I’d say give J-Lo a season to get it right. We’re mid table in a league with a couple of very good teams, and other big clubs who are struggling.
Just my tuppence worth on the Ings debate, I do not know the length of his contract but it is not for ever, I think he is popular and enjoys his role in the squad so why shouldn’t he stick around even if he does not expect to get that many pitch minutes, when his contract is up, whereupon he may be offered a smaller contract, he can then make a decision regarding his future assuming there are options open to him.
In my opinion it is unlikely to simply be a “motivated” by money thing but one where he probably realizes he is on a good thing but is also enjoying his interactions with the team.
Far from being definitive but when I witnessed the open training session in Florida in the summer, the one player clearly having the most fun and engaged with the training staff and the other players was Ings -
I would also be having fun and laughing if I was in Florida earning £100k a week.
Ings is doing what I think most would do. Stay, train well, hope to play and take the money unless a better offer comes in. No doubt when his contract is up he will get another one on a lot less money but at a club where he will get more game time.
I do not blame him at all for accepting a huge salary from us when it was offered. Good on him.
After starting the game well, we lose an unfortunate goal & go 1-0 down. You could say it was unlucky, but it wasn’t. It was a poor piece of football from Álvarez who - instead of going to head the ball clear - cowardly ducks & allows Savinho to pick up the ball & then the deflection. It’s those sorts of calls which are letting us down & those are the small details. If he heads the ball clear, we stay at 0-0 & who knows how the rest of the half pans out.
For the fourth goal, a nice bit of play in our own half ends with a simple pass by Kudus being misplaced. Had he not, we’d have been away on the counter instead of mindlessly lumping the ball up the field & losing it.
The second and third goals involve good movement from Haaland & Kilman losing him. Ok, you could blame Kilman, but he is not the first, nor will he be the last, CB to lose Haaland. Areola doesn’t cover himself in glory for the second, albeit he may not have saved it anyway.
You can say JL is not the right man, you can say he is a poor coach (whether I agree or not), but he can do nothing about Álvarez & Kudus making poor decisions or badly executing simple things. The ideas are right, but the execution of them &, perhaps, the quality of our players, are limiting us demonstrating them.
Putting a more positive spin on it, their 1st goal was an o.g. and their 4th came from a badly misplaced pass. Only Haaland's goals resulted from good attacking play just as our goal did. If we had taken the chances we created in the opening minutes who knows, there could have been a completely different outcome. Likewise if Summerville had not been called for a foul when he won the ball on the halfway line. IMO the scoreline flattered Citeh. J-Lo needs to realise that playing out from the back is not working for many of the players and that an old-fashioned boot upfield is often the best idea. Now, I think that's all my positivity for the week used up.
Maybe it’s just me but I really don’t see us as fighting that relegation battle. I think we’ll pick up enough points to be clear.
At the risk of arguing against myself, I found this bit of trivia. In Premier League history, we are the only team to have had 23 points at the halfway stage of the season and still been relegated?
Here’s a bit of trivia for you. In Premier League history, which is the only team to have had 23 points at the halfway stage of the season and still been relegated?
Here’s a bit of trivia for you. In Premier League history, which is the only team to have had 23 points at the halfway stage of the season and still been relegated?
Comments
Played pretty well imo untill we made comical mistakes that led to goals
Players need to take some responsibility, awful finishing and brain dead mistakes at the back are happening week in week out but same time Lopetegui is telling them to play from the back even though they can't and therefore it's on him to find new ways
Think both are to blame, but you can't sack the players
Wouldn't surprise me if he gets sacked, still think we aren't really at risk of relegation this season as we beat a lot of teams as good as us, we just get annihilated by the better teams
If he stays I'm OK with it, if he leaves in ok with it, but I'd prefer qe get someone new in the summer, so I'd rather we take our time finding the "right" guy then bringing back Moyes or give it to Potter or cooper who I'm not keen on
So more motivated by money than wanting to be back in management. ( If that's true, I mean.)
I would imagine that football manager contracts are more tightly written but seeing that Chelsea let him go, I doubt that they would restrict his ability to take ongoing employment, even for a competitor
They were probably desperate for him to take another job so they'd be off the financial hook!
Doubt hes had zero offers, think there couod be some concern he's either just focused on the money or he may not even wanna do the job anymore, booth of which I don't think I'd want in a manager
Yea we could get the Potter of Brighton.... but you couod argue we didn't get the Lopetegui of Wolves so think there is a valid concern there
Ings ( any player) signs a contract in which he agrees to
- be contracted to a club
- do his job ( ie turn up to training)
- keep up certain professional standards (such as diet, weight, punctuality, lifestyle).
In return, club pays agreed wages. There's no guarantee of games - it's up to the manager's judgement.
It's not like he's taking money to loll about in Dubai. Or he's shirking training. He's doing his job, and part of the job is being a squad player. If we took your idea on board, we'd say every player who wasn't being picked in the starting 11 on a regular basis was only interested in the ££££. Clearly that's not true.
In the Potter case, he signed a contract to manage Chelsea ( with whatever criteria involved). Which he did. Chelsea wanted appoint a different manager despite being contractually bound to pay Potter's wages. So they did- both, as they had 2 contracts in place.
Potter, not a football manager any more, was being given money by Chelsea. But he wasn't carrying out any of his contractual obligations, as he had been relieved of them.
This is the new side now; Todibo, Kilman, Wan-Bissaka, Summerville, Füllkrug - all started today. Half the outfield are new signings & yet we are showing no signs of progression or developing in 6 months in terms of attack or defence. Yes, more of the ball. Yes, some nice patterns of play. Yes, more shots in games where historically we’d struggle to have one. But it needs to be more.
A manager can continue managing well into their golden years.
It could be said he’s not picking the right team, but the players need to step up for whoever is in charge.
I’m no fan of J-Lo, but is there anyone available out there who we know would get more from these players? I’d say give J-Lo a season to get it right. We’re mid table in a league with a couple of very good teams, and other big clubs who are struggling.
In my opinion it is unlikely to simply be a “motivated” by money thing but one where he probably realizes he is on a good thing but is also enjoying his interactions with the team.
Far from being definitive but when I witnessed the open training session in Florida in the summer, the one player clearly having the most fun and engaged with the training staff and the other players was Ings -
Ings is doing what I think most would do. Stay, train well, hope to play and take the money unless a better offer comes in. No doubt when his contract is up he will get another one on a lot less money but at a club where he will get more game time.
I do not blame him at all for accepting a huge salary from us when it was offered. Good on him.
For the fourth goal, a nice bit of play in our own half ends with a simple pass by Kudus being misplaced. Had he not, we’d have been away on the counter instead of mindlessly lumping the ball up the field & losing it.
The second and third goals involve good movement from Haaland & Kilman losing him. Ok, you could blame Kilman, but he is not the first, nor will he be the last, CB to lose Haaland. Areola doesn’t cover himself in glory for the second, albeit he may not have saved it anyway.
You can say JL is not the right man, you can say he is a poor coach (whether I agree or not), but he can do nothing about Álvarez & Kudus making poor decisions or badly executing simple things. The ideas are right, but the execution of them &, perhaps, the quality of our players, are limiting us demonstrating them.
If we had taken the chances we created in the opening minutes who knows, there could have been a completely different outcome.
Likewise if Summerville had not been called for a foul when he won the ball on the halfway line.
IMO the scoreline flattered Citeh.
J-Lo needs to realise that playing out from the back is not working for many of the players and that an old-fashioned boot upfield is often the best idea.
Now, I think that's all my positivity for the week used up.
2003-2004 season
I think we got relegated at the end of the 2002-2003 season