FloRad ;ok 100% agree about OxCham. Depends I suppose on what our intetnions are for the rest of the season I guess. If the board are happy with top ten and not a lot else more then we've probaby got enought for that.
However, if they want top 7 - and it's possible if not likely - then they need to invest now to give us the best possible chance. Although it's unlikely to offer a European spot this time round so I doubt they'll be aiming that high, TBH
Florin it's not a case of Bilic not liking Fletcher. He was always bought as one for the future and not a regular first team starter. No different to the guy we've just bought from Everton.
Carroll and Sakho are our main two but both can get injured at any time, so even if it's good now, we'll be kicking ourselves if both get injured. Fletcher is young and as much as he shows nice touches, we haven't seen enough to know whether he's got the right instinct to get goals. Don't know about Calleri, though the change in team spirit post-Payet might lift Feghouli, Calleri and Ayew. If we count Antonio as a striker, then we might need another winger.
Thorn - I don't believe Slav dislikes Fletcher, he was bought under his stewardship and is regularly on the bench so must like the lad. What I meant was he currently doesn't fully trust him, ie when Carroll was out using Ant up top Fletch still on bench, now bringing Calleri on in preference etc.
While I agree that is what he was brought in for: the future; the willingness or not to play him now, if he is trusted or not makes a difference for if we need another striker in now or not. Part of me would trust Fletch, try him out as Carrolls backup until the summer, bring another striker in then rather than now.
However contrary to that the reports on Hogan look good, and I'm all for bringing in good players that will improve us long term when they become available. ;ok
The talk is that Fletcher may go to Leeds on loan if we sign Hogan. I'm surprised he's effectively fourth choice striker, even with Sakho injured, because he's shown a lot of promise.
Slav is clearly a fan of loaning the first team fringe youngsters (Samuelsen, Burke, Cullen, Martinez, Browne) so it wouldn't surprise me if Fletcher followed suit.
Yep, I put on here coupla days ago something similar brookings. We seem to have success dipping into the Championship to sieve for gold, so far it has given us Cresswell, Antonio and Byram...
Yep, I put on here coupla days ago something similar brookings. We seem to have success dipping into the Championship to sieve for gold, so far it has given us Cresswell, Antonio and Byram...
True alderz ;ok all very quite at the moment very strange ;hmm
But to be fair, a lot of us (myself included) were critical of the club when they were broadcasting every bit of business we were trying to do, particularly The Insider, so if this is the alternative then we shouldn't really complain (as frustrating as it is) ;ok
The only area IMO we really need to improve now is a striker .. While we were without Bryram for a bit of time we were caught short, & I wanted a RB in, but now fit , you could argue the same with our LB situation, what if Cresswell gets injured, Arthur is currently injured... We are mid table and should remain there, baring a disaster or a unbelievably good run ... So take stock and do our main business in the summer... Just sort the Dimi saga out
We at least are not as down as Sunderland.. I mean if u r gutted that Victor Anichabee is out for months and then have to to deal with the wonderful news of signing tefal Lescott ... #defoehandyourtransferrequestin ;ok
Then I can see why he'd want to move, but if he did he'd have suitors much better placed to meet his ambitions than we could. I'd love to have him here, don't get me wrong, but I just can't see it.
I dont think we need much and if the right player isnt available then we should wait until the summer; why waste the money on a pointless stop gap, when we have the resources to accommodate until the summer and there only 16 games left for us because we are out of all cups- that should also aid the fitness+ injury situations as well.
In terms of RB, as long as Byram can keep fit during the transfer window then we should be fine. Byram 1st choice, Nordviedt has done reasonably well there when given protection, Kouyate could easily fill in there as could Antonio, as he did did last season although its not ideal, whilst there is also the option to play no RB and change system to 3 at the back. which has worked very well at times.
I dont think the right kind of players are available in this window, although there is the odd exception like Fonte, so unless we are totally convinced on the player, then we should try to sign them on loan with a view to permanent so we can protect ourselves and really check them out before committing to them. I think we need a pacy, direct winger who is left footed (only really have cresswell) and perhaps a forward as well because the situation around calleri is unclear and Sakho should be eased back, but i'm still a fan of Sakho and hope he stays and signs a new deal.
I like Modou Barrow from swansea, very quick and direct, tore us to shreds last season and has good ability, and although not the complete package, he is in interesting option who would add another dimension for us because we do lack out and out pace. Whilst Bojan I think would fit in really well and would get more from what we already have; he naturally drops deep and would link upvwell with Carroll, Lanzini, feghouli, antonio, noble but is also a threat in the box and a scorer of all different types of goals. Both players rumoured to be up for a transfer, so I'd try to bring them in on loans and see how they do. In the summer is the time to do business.
Comments
Yeah, replace one moody Frenchman with another one ;nonono
However, if they want top 7 - and it's possible if not likely - then they need to invest now to give us the best possible chance. Although it's unlikely to offer a European spot this time round so I doubt they'll be aiming that high, TBH
Carroll and Sakho are our main two but both can get injured at any time, so even if it's good now, we'll be kicking ourselves if both get injured. Fletcher is young and as much as he shows nice touches, we haven't seen enough to know whether he's got the right instinct to get goals. Don't know about Calleri, though the change in team spirit post-Payet might lift Feghouli, Calleri and Ayew. If we count Antonio as a striker, then we might need another winger.
If Byram gets injured, there's no replacement.
While I agree that is what he was brought in for: the future; the willingness or not to play him now, if he is trusted or not makes a difference for if we need another striker in now or not. Part of me would trust Fletch, try him out as Carrolls backup until the summer, bring another striker in then rather than now.
Slav is clearly a fan of loaning the first team fringe youngsters (Samuelsen, Burke, Cullen, Martinez, Browne) so it wouldn't surprise me if Fletcher followed suit.
You only get let down by transfer rumours if you put any stock in them, though.
If you assume that every ITK is actually talking nonsense (except the verified ones like Big Oli) then you don't need to get let down.
While we were without Bryram for a bit of time we were caught short, & I wanted a RB in, but now fit , you could argue the same with our LB situation, what if Cresswell gets injured, Arthur is currently injured...
We are mid table and should remain there, baring a disaster or a unbelievably good run ...
So take stock and do our main business in the summer...
Just sort the Dimi saga out
I mean if u r gutted that Victor Anichabee is out for months and then have to to deal with the wonderful news of signing tefal Lescott ... #defoehandyourtransferrequestin ;ok
Martial? No chance, IMO. I think if he does leave Man U it will be for someone much bigger than us.
As mentioned in an earlier post, I think OxCham is a realistic option in the summer but he'll cost at least £20m in today's market
Ashley Young, on the other hand...
In terms of RB, as long as Byram can keep fit during the transfer window then we should be fine. Byram 1st choice, Nordviedt has done reasonably well there when given protection, Kouyate could easily fill in there as could Antonio, as he did did last season although its not ideal, whilst there is also the option to play no RB and change system to 3 at the back. which has worked very well at times.
I dont think the right kind of players are available in this window, although there is the odd exception like Fonte, so unless we are totally convinced on the player, then we should try to sign them on loan with a view to permanent so we can protect ourselves and really check them out before committing to them. I think we need a pacy, direct winger who is left footed (only really have cresswell) and perhaps a forward as well because the situation around calleri is unclear and Sakho should be eased back, but i'm still a fan of Sakho and hope he stays and signs a new deal.
I like Modou Barrow from swansea, very quick and direct, tore us to shreds last season and has good ability, and although not the complete package, he is in interesting option who would add another dimension for us because we do lack out and out pace. Whilst Bojan I think would fit in really well and would get more from what we already have; he naturally drops deep and would link upvwell with Carroll, Lanzini, feghouli, antonio, noble but is also a threat in the box and a scorer of all different types of goals. Both players rumoured to be up for a transfer, so I'd try to bring them in on loans and see how they do. In the summer is the time to do business.
Can't remember if I've said that already.