As someone who has been incredibly frustrated by Carroll's injury record (like most of us), why on earth would you want us to sign a guy who has played the same amount of games over the last few years?
As someone who has been incredibly frustrated by Carroll's injury record (like most of us), why on earth would you want us to sign a guy who has played the same amount of games over the last few years?
On his day a very good player. The frustration I and many others have with Carroll is because we have relied so heavily on him as we've had no back up. It has been 'Carroll injured, season over' Wilshere would be different because we have cover in his position
As someone who has been incredibly frustrated by Carroll's injury record (like most of us), why on earth would you want us to sign a guy who has played the same amount of games over the last few years?
On his day a very good player. The frustration I and many others have with Carroll is because we have relied so heavily on him as we've had no back up. It has been 'Carroll injured, season over' Wilshere would be different because we have cover in his position
So it's alright wasting money on him because he'd be less valuable to the team? ;hmm
I genuinely believe he could have been a good option at LAM, and that in our league that was his best position, cutting in and cracking it with his right peg. However, it appears he didn't really fit in with the squad / country, and Bilic didn't fancy him, so I'll trust it was the right decision to get rid.
That is sort of my point Champo. He has the skills but we all agree he is lightweight and inconsistent. Thereby if he put on some muscle (easily doable for a professional player) he wouldn't be so lightweight. If he worked harder in training, maybe he would be less inconsistent (not necessarily though). Although of course its all ifs and buts, I just think he could have been a good premiership LAM/LW if he had done the above.
An injury to one of the main three CM's and it's Fernandes (more an attacking CM from what I've seen) or Cullen. Not that I'm against either playing, but if that was for a prolonged period (say months rather than weeks), you're going to be putting huge pressure on those guys at their ages to produce at PL level.
I think one of Snodgrass/Feghouli will go (actually think both could go), leaving us with Ayew, Antonio and Arnautovic as wide options. That's almost £50m worth of spending there. We may look for a loan should both Snodgrass and Feghouli leave. Rumours gathering pace that Adrian is off to Palace too, so we will need a GK.
Is not a bad XI, but there are ?'s over several of those players. We know that Adrian, Kouyate and Carroll can do the business, but the latter is unreliable. Ayew should be able to but was very 50-50 in season one. Collins and Fonte have a combined age of almost 70 and the full-backs are both young. Cullen and Fernandes likewise. Feghouli has not pulled up trees. So again you've got a very strong first XI selection of players, but the back-up options are not proven reinforcements.
Before the window closes. But we should be looking at another CM and ST after we've signed Hernandez. And then potentially one more wide player if we part with both our reserve RW options.
Comments
We are now a club that had a 20m player on the bench....
http://www.whu606.com/discussion/10235/likely-team-set-up-formation-starting-xi-for-2017-18
Yes please ;pray
The frustration I and many others have with Carroll is because we have relied so heavily on him as we've had no back up. It has been 'Carroll injured, season over'
Wilshere would be different because we have cover in his position
Discuss!
Would rather the money was spent on Kara Mbodji from Anderlecht who can cover Centre Back/ Midfield and is a friend of Kouyate.
Too inconsistent and too lightweight
He has his level and that is the Mexican league which is likely not even championship level
An injury to one of the main three CM's and it's Fernandes (more an attacking CM from what I've seen) or Cullen. Not that I'm against either playing, but if that was for a prolonged period (say months rather than weeks), you're going to be putting huge pressure on those guys at their ages to produce at PL level.
I think one of Snodgrass/Feghouli will go (actually think both could go), leaving us with Ayew, Antonio and Arnautovic as wide options. That's almost £50m worth of spending there. We may look for a loan should both Snodgrass and Feghouli leave. Rumours gathering pace that Adrian is off to Palace too, so we will need a GK.
But, as it stands, a second XI of:
Adrian
Byram - Collins - Fonte - Masuaku
Kouyate - Cullen
Feghouli - Fernandes - Ayew
Carroll
Is not a bad XI, but there are ?'s over several of those players. We know that Adrian, Kouyate and Carroll can do the business, but the latter is unreliable. Ayew should be able to but was very 50-50 in season one. Collins and Fonte have a combined age of almost 70 and the full-backs are both young. Cullen and Fernandes likewise. Feghouli has not pulled up trees. So again you've got a very strong first XI selection of players, but the back-up options are not proven reinforcements.
Looking at what remains, I'd say we could lose:
Adrian - £8m
Collins - £3m
Snodgrass - £8m
Feghouli - £5m
Another £25m ish potentially there.
Before the window closes. But we should be looking at another CM and ST after we've signed Hernandez. And then potentially one more wide player if we part with both our reserve RW options.