If we really do not think he brings anything to the team then we need to cut bait and accept the best offer out there that represents what someone is willing to pay.
Whilst I agree with all you say, the reason not to accept the first offer, is that a better one (either from the same club or a different one) may come in.
The same as when we put in an offer to buy a player, we rarely go in straightaway with what the selling club is asking for. Means we miss out on (a lot of) players, but get the occasional one for a discount.
What makes the Fullkrug situation so bad is that it was always going to be a shockingly bad buy, so I guess we're trying to avoid a shockingly bad sell as well.
Why was it always going to be a shockingly bad buy. He was Germany’s striker and had been banging in goals in the Euros. Trouble has always been we don’t know how to use strikers. We had Haller, Scamacca and Fullkrug and turned them into bad buys.
Why was it always going to be a shockingly bad buy. He was Germany’s striker and had been banging in goals in the Euros. Trouble has always been we don’t know how to use strikers. We had Haller, Scamacca and Fullkrug and turned them into bad buys.
We paid far too much money for a 31 year old player, playing outside Germany for the first time in his career at that age, with a history of recurring injuries (yes, I know he had a decent season just before we bought him) on a surprisingly long and very well paid contract.
Given we were never going to recoup a decent fee if we tried to sell him at any point in his contract, he would have had to have had an amazing, completely injury-free time with us just to be reasonable value for money. Completely predictably that hasn't happened.
In Taty we have a striker that can score and fit in with our style of play, we need to keep him. We have had good strikers before, Haller, Scamacca and Fullkrug to name some who couldn't for some reason do it for us.
In Taty we have a striker that can score and fit in with our style of play, we need to keep him. We have had good strikers before, Haller, Scamacca and Fullkrug to name some who couldn't for some reason do it for us.
I thought that Scamacca was pretty good for us, but he just couldn't settle in the UK.
Shame really, as he could have been brilliant for us
Personally, I would not spend significant money on a striker. Whoever we go for will not be better than Taty. We have Taty & Pablo, we have Bowen. What we need are the midfield/wide areas sorted. Two wingers, an AM/CM player & a CB. If we sort that & have the budget left, a cheap striker on loan or a free would be ideal.
Areola, Veltman, Scarles, Magassa, Orford, Ward-Prowse, Lamadrid, WG/AM, ST
With Souček to return in October.
Still need another wide player, AM/ST depending if we want to keep using this 4-4-2 hybrid system or want to be able to mix it up with a number 10 style player. Also likely to need a CB. Think we’re ok in CM personally, at full-back, in goal & up front.
Areola, Veltman, Scarles, Magassa, Orford, Ward-Prowse, Lamadrid, WG/AM, ST
With Souček to return in October.
Still need another wide player, AM/ST depending if we want to keep using this 4-4-2 hybrid system or want to be able to mix it up with a number 10 style player. Also likely to need a CB. Think we’re ok in CM personally, at full-back, in goal & up front.
In addition to Scarles, Orford and Kante, other promising academy players need some encouragement too. Fearon, Ajala, Myers, Earthy and Golambeckis come to mind. Without some senior game time, they are likely to be feel neglected and will be be poached by rival teams.
Myers I can see being the only one there with first team potential this season, the rest get loaned/sold IMO. Scarles, Orford & Kante will be in & around the squad.
Comments
The same as when we put in an offer to buy a player, we rarely go in straightaway with what the selling club is asking for. Means we miss out on (a lot of) players, but get the occasional one for a discount.
What makes the Fullkrug situation so bad is that it was always going to be a shockingly bad buy, so I guess we're trying to avoid a shockingly bad sell as well.
Trouble has always been we don’t know how to use strikers. We had Haller, Scamacca and Fullkrug and turned them into bad buys.
Given we were never going to recoup a decent fee if we tried to sell him at any point in his contract, he would have had to have had an amazing, completely injury-free time with us just to be reasonable value for money. Completely predictably that hasn't happened.
Shame really, as he could have been brilliant for us
I assume a back up option if Solomon doesn’t go through
Walker-Peters - Mavropanos - Kilman - Diouf
Álvarez - Kanté
Bowen - Pablo - Solomon
Taty
Areola, Veltman, Scarles, Magassa, Orford, Ward-Prowse, Lamadrid, WG/AM, ST
With Souček to return in October.
Still need another wide player, AM/ST depending if we want to keep using this 4-4-2 hybrid system or want to be able to mix it up with a number 10 style player. Also likely to need a CB. Think we’re ok in CM personally, at full-back, in goal & up front.
https://www.whufc.com/en/news/west-ham-united-sign-manor-solomon
I think he’s another smart, clever signing, to go along with Veltman, & at £5m it is a sensible bit of business & likely a bargain
Strength in depth is key and we need to keep looking
I can’t keep up with the terminology.😃