MrsG, At least we are consistent with our views. Apologies but comments about NES are relevant to todays game or is that wrong?
Have to agree really, they sort of go hand in hand, I mean his selection for today, his constant playing of his favourite pets, Mads not being dropped, sometimes it's difficult to split the two.....IMO.....But I'm, not the boss here!
Yeh every time he collects the ball from the net after a goal. How NES keeps faith in his is just another baffling example of his stubbornness, this is a comment about Mads though, he needs dropping IMO.
Once again we have no leader of the defence, same as last season. He will change it in the same way he did in January but the question will be if it will be too late. Last season we had dropped too many points before Desai came in and this term we may not have secured the points before he sealed the leak. Six goals conceded in two matches at home is just not good enough for any side, let alone the favourites for promotion.
I am also not convinced by Engals but feel Nuno may be a little loyal to him as he was his big summer purchase. I recall looking on the Celtic forum when we bought him and most comments were that he has a great game in him but you don't get to see it too often.
We have a big problem in that too many of our lot appear to have the attitude that they’re too good for this league but an even bigger problem is that they’re incapable of proving it even if it were true. There seems a distinct lack of spirit and full on effort which against opponents which show 100% of both leaves us trailing as shown today and last week. Until we learn we need to match our opponents in effort and application any advantage in talent or experience will be nullified.
Just too much of not being very good, being startled by the round bouncy thing coming at them at speed, and looking like they aren't quite sure of exactly what other guys in the same kit are going to do.
Just too much of not being very good, being startled by the round bouncy thing coming at them at speed, and looking like they aren't quite sure of exactly what other guys in the same kit are going to do.
That sounds like a bunch of strangers are playing with each other which should not be the case 👍🏻
For the Cardiff match I feel NES must really change it up, sadly yet again. But this time I believe it very necessary 👍🏻 In fact in all areas of the pitch starting with Mads in goal….
I agree. But how many of our first XI have played together for any extended period?
For me, the defensive line ( CB pairing especially) + keeper is fundamental. And that takes...half a season? to build. I don't rate the keeper, so that makes it harder.
Rest of the team, too many new players to be able to have a cohesive unit yet.
Also, Bowen is fab. And the opposition give him about 10cm of space once he gets the ball. Which makes it hard for him to bring a teammate into play, and also we don't have anyone else who poses such a threat So as long as they close him down, we are stymied.
Which points to the fact that we don't have enough quality throughout the team.
Today we were good at keeping possession (pass accuracy) but WBA were solid with 2 banks of 4 when we had possession.
And we were both slow to play forward, and couldn't split the defence with anything unexpected.
I know a lot of people wanted us to move to being a possession based team. But it feels like that's not playing to our strengths. ( If we have any 😆)
I do not know what goes on behind the scenes but something is not right. Does Nuno know what team he wants to field?
We don't have stability in defence. Full-backs have been chopped and changed. We have the worst defensive record in the top eight teams and the plague of weak defence has followed us for some time.
In midfield, Nuno has tried to accommodate Engels, Mukasa and Kante and it has not worked. Despite a glut of midfield players, we rarely dominate the midfield. Nuno had similar problems last year but eventually found Soucek and Fernandes combination to be best in midfield, but it was too late to save us.
Today, we played without a proven goal-scorer. Pablo and Kante are not proven strikers. We played Kante and Taty against Southampton. After going behind, Nuno switches to 3-5-2 or 3-4-3, which gives us a bit of momentum but also leaves us open to counter-attack.
Maybe it is all down to Nuno's tactics and man management skills.
We haven’t found a balance, the best front balance is IMO:
Bowen - Mukasa - Engels - Solomon Pablo Taty
But Souček for Mukasa in certain games.
Playing Pablo up top alone makes him worse, playing Kante & Mukasa makes them both worse with no protection behind them, Morato is a limited LB & KWP is targeted as a RB. We are also far more secure at the back with Veltman at RB (the stats speak for themselves), yet he was left on the bench yesterday. We all know Mads doesn’t make any saves.
We have shown we can play to a very high standard - Wrexham home - but it hasn’t happened outside of that game. We were fortunate v Millwall, QPR & Swansea recently, then Saints & WBA found us out. We started the season slowly (Burnley, Charlton, Watford), before a little run of wins where we weren’t overly convincing (Wolves, Derby, Bolton).
Our biggest wins came with a 4-4-2 (Wolves, Derby, Wrexham, Lincoln). That’s what Nuno needs to stick to, it’s the best that we have with what we have. Any two of Pablo, Taty, Piroe.
I don’t know why Nuno & the coaches can’t settle on a system, put players into it in their best positions & drill a side that knows what it’s doing. With our quality & the right mentality, that would take us up.
Problem though with that @Lukerz , IMO in NES' eyes Kante is somewhat undroppable....
Like you said, you can't see why NES & his coaches can't settle on a system, I think it's unforgivable that it's taking him this long and he still hasn't sussed it out, even the commentator yesterday said ' we don't have an identity '
But I'm not going to talk just about NES, whatever he tells the players simply isn't sinking in.
The players also need to look at themselves, some of the performances yesterday were horrendous, but again, it's not been great all season despite some very good results. Bowen, even though he was probably our best player, as a captain, he also needs to do more IMO....
I don't know the way forward, just gotta hope NES does, also, I can't remember many matches where I thought Engels has done enough, a couple of games perhaps, but again IMO that and he isn't good enough from what I've seen so far.....However from what I have read elsewhere it could be where he is being played and his responsibilities, which are different to what he had at Celtic.....
It's all a mess at the moment, and NES is in a whirlwind, come Wednesday, anything less than 3 points, I think a few more thousand fans will start to turn on him, it's already happening for sure.......
NES needs to work out his best players, where to play them and change it up only when necessary....It's been chop and change all season, and not always because of injuries, because he doesn't seem to know.....
I guess KWP will be out for a bit, so looks like Veltman will have to play....That's not a bad thing.... Not sure where Scarles was yesterday......Perhaps he or Mayers need to come back in and Morato moves into CB, even though Golambekis was ok, perhaps it could be considered....
NES has some big decisions to make and the pressure is on him.
Also, if Alvarez is fit, IMO he needs to be re-included in the squad..... There has to be a way of getting him back in, otherwise, what's the point.....
Oh well, Cardiff this week is a big game for us and NES IMO.....
Didn't see the game yesterday (a 60th birthday to attend) but watched the highlights today. The ease with which WBA scored their first goal would embarrass a Sunday pub team's defence, let alone a professional team with many international players, absolutely shocking.
Didn't see the game yesterday (a 60th birthday to attend) but watched the highlights today. The ease with which WBA scored their first goal would embarrass a Sunday pub team's defence, let alone a professional team with many international players, absolutely shocking.
Yeah, it was truly shocking, I'm not sure who was most at fault. Mukasa is the player that tries to close down the player who played the through ball, but he had been marking someone else and I think it was KWP's player that came short to receive the ball and KWP didn't follow him and allowed him all the time in the world to pick his pass.
Then the ball just takes out both Kilman and Morato, which really shouldn't happen, and you've got to criticise Golembeckis as well for letting his man get goalside of him far too easily.
Didn't see the game yesterday (a 60th birthday to attend) but watched the highlights today. The ease with which WBA scored their first goal would embarrass a Sunday pub team's defence, let alone a professional team with many international players, absolutely shocking.
Yeah, it was truly shocking, I'm not sure who was most at fault. Mukasa is the player that tries to close down the player who played the through ball, but he had been marking someone else and I think it was KWP's player that came short to receive the ball and KWP didn't follow him and allowed him all the time in the world to pick his pass.
Then the ball just takes out both Kilman and Morato, which really shouldn't happen, and you've got to criticise Golembeckis as well for letting his man get goalside of him far too easily.
If you just watch KWP every game, his defensive positioning & decision-making is horrendous, even if he seems to not do anything obviously bad in the game. Really does weaken our defending as a unit.
Didn't see the game yesterday (a 60th birthday to attend) but watched the highlights today. The ease with which WBA scored their first goal would embarrass a Sunday pub team's defence, let alone a professional team with many international players, absolutely shocking.
I particularly enjoyed the 4-2-4 formation we employed shortly before they cut us open with 2 passes
It's a defence thing as 6 goals at home in two matches tells us.
It's looking at present like a disjointed window in that we have too many attack minded midfielders and lack a solid DM, we also didn't replace Disasi and hoped Kilman could cut it in the Championship.
We rightly got excited when we were scoring all those goals at the start as it showed we had done good attacking transfer business, but now we find the neglect of the defence is biting us. It will get corrected in the winter window I have no doubt, we just need to make sure we are in the fight at that point.
It's a defence thing as 6 goals at home in two matches tells us.
It's looking at present like a disjointed window in that we have too many attack minded midfielders and lack a solid DM, we also didn't replace Disasi and hoped Kilman could cut it in the Championship.
We rightly got excited when we were scoring all those goals at the start as it showed we had done good attacking transfer business, but now we find the neglect of the defence is biting us. It will get corrected in the winter window I have no doubt, we just need to make sure we are in the fight at that point.
There are 2 players that one featured on the bench this weekend and one vanished and not to be seen, they are defensive midfielders, but not chosen to join In, whoever the blame lies with, they could fill a gap IMO 👍🏻⚒️
But what has Magassa done to suggest he’s the answer to our midfield problems? I’ve seen him play one game where he played well (Man Utd away), otherwise he runs around like a headless chicken. He’s certainly not a disciplined DM.
As for Alvarez, we don’t know what is going on there. Seems to have a lot of off field issues. However, when he has played for us under Moyes & Lop, again, he was hardly an outstandingly mature DM.
I’d like to see Magassa at this level. I think there were a few times where he looked good in the PL and plenty when he wasn’t so great but he’s young and and maybe a level down would be a good chance to let him learn.
But I also don’t think he’s going to solve problems for us. Not sure he’s got that much defensive discipline and think he was best when pressing higher.
Comments
How NES keeps faith in his is just another baffling example of his stubbornness, this is a comment about Mads though, he needs dropping IMO.
I am also not convinced by Engals but feel Nuno may be a little loyal to him as he was his big summer purchase. I recall looking on the Celtic forum when we bought him and most comments were that he has a great game in him but you don't get to see it too often.
Until we learn we need to match our opponents in effort and application any advantage in talent or experience will be nullified.
Just too much of not being very good, being startled by the round bouncy thing coming at them at speed, and looking like they aren't quite sure of exactly what other guys in the same kit are going to do.
In fact in all areas of the pitch starting with Mads in goal….
https://www.claretandhugh.info/is-this-the-beginning-of-the-end-for-nuno-fans-are-losing-patience/
I didn’t copy and paste this, but after now reading it, we have similar views 👍🏻
I agree. But how many of our first XI have played together for any extended period?
For me, the defensive line ( CB pairing especially) + keeper is fundamental. And that takes...half a season? to build.
I don't rate the keeper, so that makes it harder.
Rest of the team, too many new players to be able to have a cohesive unit yet.
Also, Bowen is fab. And the opposition give him about 10cm of space once he gets the ball. Which makes it hard for him to bring a teammate into play, and also we don't have anyone else who poses such a threat
So as long as they close him down, we are stymied.
Which points to the fact that we don't have enough quality throughout the team.
And we were both slow to play forward, and couldn't split the defence with anything unexpected.
I know a lot of people wanted us to move to being a possession based team. But it feels like that's not playing to our strengths. ( If we have any 😆)
We don't have stability in defence. Full-backs have been chopped and changed. We have the worst defensive record in the top eight teams and the plague of weak defence has followed us for some time.
In midfield, Nuno has tried to accommodate Engels, Mukasa and Kante and it has not worked. Despite a glut of midfield players, we rarely dominate the midfield. Nuno had similar problems last year but eventually found Soucek and Fernandes combination to be best in midfield, but it was too late to save us.
Today, we played without a proven goal-scorer. Pablo and Kante are not proven strikers. We played Kante and Taty against Southampton. After going behind, Nuno switches to 3-5-2 or 3-4-3, which gives us a bit of momentum but also leaves us open to counter-attack.
Maybe it is all down to Nuno's tactics and man management skills.
Bowen - Mukasa - Engels - Solomon
Pablo
Taty
But Souček for Mukasa in certain games.
Playing Pablo up top alone makes him worse, playing Kante & Mukasa makes them both worse with no protection behind them, Morato is a limited LB & KWP is targeted as a RB. We are also far more secure at the back with Veltman at RB (the stats speak for themselves), yet he was left on the bench yesterday. We all know Mads doesn’t make any saves.
We have shown we can play to a very high standard - Wrexham home - but it hasn’t happened outside of that game. We were fortunate v Millwall, QPR & Swansea recently, then Saints & WBA found us out. We started the season slowly (Burnley, Charlton, Watford), before a little run of wins where we weren’t overly convincing (Wolves, Derby, Bolton).
Our biggest wins came with a 4-4-2 (Wolves, Derby, Wrexham, Lincoln). That’s what Nuno needs to stick to, it’s the best that we have with what we have. Any two of Pablo, Taty, Piroe.
I don’t know why Nuno & the coaches can’t settle on a system, put players into it in their best positions & drill a side that knows what it’s doing. With our quality & the right mentality, that would take us up.
Like you said, you can't see why NES & his coaches can't settle on a system, I think it's unforgivable that it's taking him this long and he still hasn't sussed it out, even the commentator yesterday said ' we don't have an identity '
But I'm not going to talk just about NES, whatever he tells the players simply isn't sinking in.
The players also need to look at themselves, some of the performances yesterday were horrendous, but again, it's not been great all season despite some very good results.
Bowen, even though he was probably our best player, as a captain, he also needs to do more IMO....
I don't know the way forward, just gotta hope NES does, also, I can't remember many matches where I thought Engels has done enough, a couple of games perhaps, but again IMO that and he isn't good enough from what I've seen so far.....However from what I have read elsewhere it could be where he is being played and his responsibilities, which are different to what he had at Celtic.....
It's all a mess at the moment, and NES is in a whirlwind, come Wednesday, anything less than 3 points, I think a few more thousand fans will start to turn on him, it's already happening for sure.......
NES needs to work out his best players, where to play them and change it up only when necessary....It's been chop and change all season, and not always because of injuries, because he doesn't seem to know.....
I guess KWP will be out for a bit, so looks like Veltman will have to play....That's not a bad thing....
Not sure where Scarles was yesterday......Perhaps he or Mayers need to come back in and Morato moves into CB, even though Golambekis was ok, perhaps it could be considered....
NES has some big decisions to make and the pressure is on him.
Also, if Alvarez is fit, IMO he needs to be re-included in the squad.....
There has to be a way of getting him back in, otherwise, what's the point.....
Oh well, Cardiff this week is a big game for us and NES IMO.....
Then the ball just takes out both Kilman and Morato, which really shouldn't happen, and you've got to criticise Golembeckis as well for letting his man get goalside of him far too easily.
I commented about Engels and how poor I think he was / has been for most games, I’m not alone.
It mentions players that 1 or 2 sometimes don’t even make the squad,
It's looking at present like a disjointed window in that we have too many attack minded midfielders and lack a solid DM, we also didn't replace Disasi and hoped Kilman could cut it in the Championship.
We rightly got excited when we were scoring all those goals at the start as it showed we had done good attacking transfer business, but now we find the neglect of the defence is biting us. It will get corrected in the winter window I have no doubt, we just need to make sure we are in the fight at that point.
As for Alvarez, we don’t know what is going on there. Seems to have a lot of off field issues. However, when he has played for us under Moyes & Lop, again, he was hardly an outstandingly mature DM.
But I also don’t think he’s going to solve problems for us. Not sure he’s got that much defensive discipline and think he was best when pressing higher.